Nick's Place Winthrop

Nick's Place Winthrop is a beloved culinary gem nestled at 70 Pauline St, Winthrop, MA, offering an irresistible blend of classic American flavors with a seafood-focused twist. This vibrant restaurant and takeaway spot is renowned for its expansive menu that beautifully caters to diverse cravings—from succulent seafood sandwiches and fresh, crisp salads to hearty subs and indulgent New York-style cheesecake.

Step inside or grab a meal to go and prepare to be greeted with warm, attentive service that turns every visit into a special occasion. Guests consistently highlight the exceptional hospitality, especially praising Gabriella, whose friendly demeanor and expert menu suggestions elevate the overall dining experience. Whether stopping by for a quick lunch or settling in for a relaxed family dinner, the welcoming atmosphere at Nick’s Place feels genuinely like home.

The cuisine is a feast for the senses. Dive into their signature Lobster Roll, where tender lobster meat meets a perfectly toasted roll, creating a harmonious balance of buttery richness and ocean-fresh delight. For those craving comfort food with depth, the Steak Bomb Sub, layered with peppers, onions, mushrooms, salami, and melted cheese, offers a savory explosion of flavors in every bite. The kitchen also masters classic takes like Pepperoni Pizza with a crisp crust and gooey cheese, as well as gluten-free options that don’t compromise on taste.

Seafood aficionados will relish the Stuffed Ravioli with Meatballs and the perfectly seasoned Seafood Risotto, both dishes balancing indulgent textures and rich, satisfying flavors. On Wednesdays, the Pasta Special invites guests to explore fresh, ever-changing offerings that keep repeat visits exciting. Sweet tooths won’t want to miss the creamy, velvety New York Style Cheesecake or the classic homemade cookies that deliver a nostalgic finish to the meal.

Regulars rave about the generous portions and consistent quality. Brandon Converse shares his “excellent experience” savoring the “fantastic baked haddock, fried scallops, and BBQ roast beef.” Maheshwar Singh calls the service “one of the best experiences in the last 10 years,” highlighting the calzone as a “super duty item.” Meanwhile, Peter J Maldonado insists on the “honey steak tips” as a must-try specialty. These authentic endorsements underscore not only the flawless execution of the food but also the genuine care that fuels every interaction.

Nick’s Place Winthrop successfully serves as a vibrant crossroads where hearty New England seafood meets classic deli favorites, all wrapped in an inviting atmosphere that makes every guest feel valued. For those in Winthrop or passing through, this restaurant is a definitive stop to enjoy flavorful, thoughtfully prepared meals and warm hospitality that truly sets it apart.